Fair Performance Evaluation and Work Environment - Associate Director EY Employee Review

2.0
Feb 13, 2017
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

EY offers a wast array of opportunities and, in general, provides an inclusive team environment. That's what drew me to accept an offer in the first place.

Cons

Comments on Cons always come with the flavor of a disgruntled ex-employee. Therefore, I'm trying to give you the facts and let you decide. EY's annual performance rating is numerical 1 to 5, as in so many other companies. in 2015 I was rated on the high end of the scale , then a re-org happened and I was assigned a new manager. Same role, same responsibility, same internal customers and stakeholders, same teams to support in the EST time zone, just a new manager now 16 hrs ahead in time zones. During the 2016 performance review all feedback from internal customers, stakeholders and partners was positive, every one of them expressed appreciation of the work I delivered. My new manager, however, not so much. All positive feedback was discredited, only her opinion was allowed leading to a below average rating, a forced performance improvement plan without measurable goals and ultimately to my termination from EY. And HR backed the managers decisions all along this process. Questions I raised remained unanswered and facts I presented were not checked nor taken into consideration. So if you are willing to take that chance that a firm allows managers to lead teams dictatorial, that feedback of internal partners and stakeholders is encouraged but can ultimately be ignored and HR allows such managers to bypass company policies and procedures encouraging such leadership style, EY could be the right place for you !

Explore other reviews about EY

5.0
Jan 21, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Great experience and people to work with

Cons

Long hours during busy season

5.0
Feb 21, 2018
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

1. You will have a very hard time not falling in love with every single person you meet there. 2. Seriously, you will meet your soul mate(s) there. 3. Prestigious and looks great on the resume. 4. Your brain will grow a thousand times more powerful. 5. Forces you to conquer your fear of public speaking. 6. Fun team bonding and lifelong friends. 7. Stepping stone to high paying jobs. 8. Helps you work on perfecting your charm. You will learn from the most charming people how to really get people to like you. 9. HR really cares. 10. Big support network (IT, creative services, etc.). 11. Teaches you to be calm and in control.

Cons

OK, I'm going to be discussing all the taboo things, and there are a lot of them. In spite of these cons, I still admit it's worth a five star rating. 1. High performers are "designated" (you have very little control over your rating) by the partner group (can be a pro if you get selected. Seriously, I have worked with some of the supposed "fives" and they are not any different than my threes and fours. 2. Quality is extremely low. Sometimes I felt like I was working at McDonalds and not a professional services firm. The emphasis is on getting through work as fast as possible and expectations for quality are not realistic. 3. EY has a very hard time firing bad employees. If you get stuck with one it can be a nightmare. 4. EY has a heavy emphasis on wasting time. For example, there are lots and lots of checklists which have no value that you have to fill out. Also, they wasted money and time on creating "Canvas" which is literally slower and more awkward than the previous workspace tool, GAMX. There is a heavy emphasis on "reinventing the wheel" and fixing problems that aren't broken with even worse solutions. Instead of wasting money on useless tools, that money could have been spent on your employees in the form of compensation. Like I said, EY is really focused on attempting to look as though value is being created when in fact it is not. 5. Lots of meetings. Appearances are very important. 6. Employees on global 360 accounts get better treatment. 7. Some employees (executives mostly) tend to overemphasize how important this work is. Let's face it, if it was really glorious work then we would have action figures. 8. Looks are very important. Seriously, if you are a girl, you will get promoted based on how hot you are (the quality of your work is largely unimportant). If you are a guy, you are treated a little better but there is still a sexist undercurrent in the environment. This is advice you won't get from HR obviously, but that doesn't mean it isn't true. 8. You will be forced to eat hours. 9. Your ethical compass will start to get weaker. 10. You will get a little cynical. 11. Lots of driving and travel. 12. "Family men" and married couples with children are more likely to be promoted. If you want to be a partner, you have to be married (few exceptions). 13. You will work on vacations. 14. Loss of relationships with family and friends. 15. Some backstabbing and credit-stealing (but not very common). 16. Comp is below market but that's to be expected. 17. Employee retention is not something management is interested in. This makes you replaceable and expendable (yes even as a manager, unless you have been "designated" as a high performer by the partner group).

1014
See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All